Justice system called ‘fundamentally racist’ – new study shows Māori more likely to go to court


This story was originally published on RNZ.co.nz and is republished with permission.

A new study has shown police are almost twice as likely to send a first-time Māori offender to court, than a Pākehā.

The JustSpeak study did a fresh analysis of police, justice and census data from 2013 and found that Māori are 1.7 times more likely to end up in court than a Pākehā offender.

It also shows Māori women who are arrested in their late teens or early 20s are twice as likely as Pākehā women to end up before a judge.

JustSpeak board member Tamatha Paul (Ngāti Awa, Waikato-Tainui) said: “As a young Māori woman reading this research, it frightens me, and then to look at the leaders of our country and see that the rhetoric is largely around punitive policy like the Armed Response trial, this doesn’t give me much hope that the government is actually committed to solving the issue of over-incarceration of Māori.

READ MORE:
* Why do Māori suffer inequality in the health system? One expert says it’s ‘white privilege’
* The Detail: Police Māori strategy a re-turning of the tide
* Police launch strategy to reduce Māori re-offending by 25 per cent
* Why a pastor who abused children served less prison time than a low-level cannabis dealer

“This illustrates the essence of what research has shown from the likes of Moana Jackson for a long time that our justice system is fundamentally racist.”

But police deputy commissioner Wally Haumaha had reservations about the study because it didn’t show what type of crime was being committed.

Tamatha Paul says the justice system is fundamentally racist.

Supplied

Tamatha Paul says the justice system is fundamentally racist.

He said the disparity may be that Māori were committing more serious offences and ineligible for programmes which diverted people away from court for low-level crimes like shop-lifting and careless driving.

“If they are being arrested at the lower end of the scale and those opportunities are not being provided, then I would be concerned.”

He said police were being trained to look at pre-charge warnings or iwi panels when they came across a first-time offender.

More than 3000 people were diverted to Te Pae Oranga instead of the courts last year.

Police were also required to undergo unconscious bias training, although it was not evident yet whether it was working.

“We’re still yet to look at an evaluative process but what we have is we’ve put leaders in place where we’ve trained many of our staff again in unconscious bias … and that training will then go into every district around the country.”

Police deputy commissioner Wally Haumaha had his doubts about the research.

Dom Thomas

Police deputy commissioner Wally Haumaha had his doubts about the research.

Hastings City councillor and community worker Henare O’Keefe said it would help if police were more involved in Māori life.

“Policeman [used to] coach the local rugby team, or they sat on the marae committee, all that sort of thing helped to build that relationship, so maybe modern day policing in order to go forward we need to go back.”

“More brown faces within the police would certainly help and maybe a noho marae for new recruits, they may not agree with it but it would at least give them an understanding and more of an empathetic approach.”

In the meantime, JustSpeak is calling on all the main political parties to work together to reduce the number of Māori in the justice system.

This story was originally published on RNZ.co.nz and is republished with permission.